Forensic and Pharmaceutical, Criminal and Legal, Social and Economic Study of the Conditions, that Cause Bribery Corruption in the System of Legal Relations "Doctor-Patient-Investigator-Lawyer"
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.53933/sspmlp.v2i3.57Keywords:
pharmaceutical law, medical law, criminal law, healthcare institutions, bribery, corruptionAbstract
Based on the forensic and pharmaceutical, criminal and legal, social and economic research, analyzed the reasons and conditions causing bribery in the field of healthcare, committed by doctors who were officials. The analysis of the forensic and pharmaceutical practice on reports of the medical expertise commission showed that there is no information about the participation of lawyers in the system of legal relations "doctor-patient-investigator-lawyer". The obtained conclusions indicate that it is necessary to increase the level of advocacy during the investigation of criminal cases at the pre-trial and judicial investigation. In addition, in order to strengthen information co-operation between doctors and officials of healthcare institutions concerning the improvement of qualifications in matters of medical and pharmaceutical law of Ukraine, necessary measures were proposed. Normative initiatives to increase the level of criminal responsibility were given. Recommended to the leadership of the KhMAPE and Public Organization "Association of Medical and Pharmaceutical Law" to appeal with a corresponding initiative to the Ministry of Health of Ukraine, the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine, the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine, the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine to prevent the causes and conditions that cause bribery among communal non-profit enterprises – healthcare institutions.
References
Evolution of the phenomenon of corruption: a historical perspective. Anticorruption lesson. 17.05.2022. URL: https://anticorruption-lesson.ed-era.com/evolucia_yavischa_korupcyy_storychnyu_rakurs.
Fact Sheet: U.S. Strategy on Countering Corruption. STATEMENTS AND RELEASES. 06.12.2021. URL: https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2021/12/06/fact-sheet-u-s-strategy-on-countering-corruption/.
United Nations Convention against Corruption. UN. 31.10.2003. URL: https://legal.un.org/avl/ha/uncc/uncc.html.
What is the European Union (EU) doing to combat corruption in EU countries? Copyright © European Union. 22.02.2021. URL: https://epthinktank.eu/2021/02/22/what-is-the-european-union-eu-doing-to-combat-corruption-in-eu-countries/.
Anti-Corruption: First review of the EU's implementation of United Nations Convention against Corruption. EC.EUROPA. 17.12.2020. URL: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_20_2416.
Ilyuk M., Busol O. Why cannot corruption be overcome in Ukraine? (Old question – new answers). Lexinform.com.ua. 11.09.2018. URL: https://lexinform.com.ua/dumka-eksperta/chomu-ne-mozhna-podolaty-koruptsiyu-v-ukrayini-stare-pytannya-novi-vidpovidi/.
Shapovalov V., Butko L., Shapovalov V. Organizational and legal study of quarantine restrictions in the spread of coronavirus disease in Ukraine. SSP Modern Pharmacy and Medicine. 2021. Vol. 1. N. 2. P. 1–12. URL: https://doi.org/10.53933/sspmpm.v1i2.23. DOI: https://doi.org/10.53933/sspmpm.v1i2.23
Shapovalova V., Shapovalov V., Shapovalov V. et al. Experience of the department of medical and pharmaceutical law, general and clinical pharmacy of the Kharkiv medical academy of postgraduate education concerning the educational process during the quarantine period caused by COVID-19. Actual Problems of Medicine and Pharmacy. 2021. Vol.2. N.2. P. 1–20. DOI: https://doi.org/10.52914/apmp.v2i2.33. DOI: https://doi.org/10.52914/apmp.v2i2.33
Hayduchok I., Shapovalov V. Forensic pharmacy and medicine: risks for pharmacotherapy of addiction and countering of illegal circulation of psychoactive substances in the COVID-19 pandemic. 2021. SSP Modern Pharmacy and Medicine. Vol. 1. N. 2. P. 1-28. URL: https://doi.org/10.53933/sspmpm.v1i2.32. DOI: https://doi.org/10.53933/sspmpm.v1i2.32
Shapovalova V.A., Zbrozhek S.I., Shapovalov V.V. et al. Forensic pharmacy: some risk factors in the formation of addictive health disorders. Acta Scientific Pharmaceutical Science. 2021. V. 4. Iss. 1. P. 7–12. DOI: 10.3180/ASPS.2020.05.0651. DOI: https://doi.org/10.31080/ASPS.2020.05.0651
Shapovalov V. (Jr.), Gudzenko А., Komar L. et al. Concerning the importance of forensic and pharmaceutical researches to improve patients’ accessibility to medicines. Pharmacia. 2017. Vol. 65. N. 2. P. 23–29. URL: http://bsphs.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Shapovalov.pdf.
Shapovalov V. (Jr.), Gudzenko A., Shapovalova V. at. el. Forensic and pharmaceutical study of the presence of a causal link between the degree of alcohol abuse and qualification level of the respondents. Pharmacia. 2017. Vol. 66. N. 3. Р. 31–39. URL: http://bsphs.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/Shapovalov.pdf.
Zbrozhek S.I., Shapovalova V.A., Shapovalov V.V. et al. Organizational and legal research of indicators of incidence and prevalence of diabetes mellitus in countryside areas. Annals of Mechnikov Institute. 2017. N. 1. P. 44–53. URL: http://www.imiamn.org.ua/journal/1_2017/zmist1_2017.html.
Shapovalov V. (Jr.), Zbrozhek S., Gudzenko A. et al. Organizational and legal analysis of the pharmaceutical provision for the most common diseases of society. International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences Review and Research. 2018. Vol. 51. N. 1. P. 118-124. URL: http://globalresearchonline.net/journalcontents/v51-1/18.pdf.
Shapovalov V.V. (Jr.), Zbrozhek S.I., Shapovalova V.O. et al. Organizational and legal evaluation of availability of medicines’ circulation for cancer patients. Pharmacia. 2018. Vol. 65. N. 2. P. 17-22. URL: http://bsphs.org/?magasine=organizational-and-legal-evaluation-of-availability-of-medicines-circulation-for-cancer-patients.
Shapovalov V.V. Organizational and legal approaches to the development of combined drugs based on psychoactive substances for the prevention and treatment of drug addiction. Dissertation for Doctor of Pharmaceutical Sciences degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology and organization of pharmaceutical business". Kyiv, 2005. 44 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0011146.
Kuznetsova T.V. Drug support for alcohol dependence therapy: dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology and organization of pharmaceutical business". Kyiv, 2006. 24 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0081252.
Shapovalov V.V., Gudzenko A.A., Zbrozhek S.I. et al. Forensic and pharmaceutical analysis of addictive morbidity because of the use of psychotropic psychoactive substances in Ukraine (retrospective aspect). Annals of Mechnikov Institute. 2018. No. 3. Р. 41–44. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.1456544. URL: http://www.imiamn.org.ua/journal/3_2018/PDF/9.pdf.
Gutorov O.I. Improving the regulatory framework for the circulation of psychoactive substances in the private sector of the regional pharmacy network. Dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology and organization of pharmaceutical business". Kharkiv, 2007. 20 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0004817.
Bondarenko V.V. Scientific substantiation of features of expert support of circulation of psychoactive substances. Dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology and organization of pharmaceutical business". Kharkiv, 2008. 22 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0108941.
Shapovalov V. (Jr.), Gudzenko A., Shapovalova V. et al. Forensic and pharmaceutical analysis of addictive morbidity because of the use of narcotic psychoactive substances in Ukraine (retrospective aspect). International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research. 2018. Vol. 3. Is. 3. P. 22-25. URL: http://www.pharmacyjournal.net/archives/2018/vol3/issue3.
Vasina Yu.V. Organizational research of forensic pharmacy to counteract the narcotization of young people with psychoactive substances. Dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology and organization of pharmaceutical business". Kharkiv, 2009. 24 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0090297.
Osyntseva A.O. Scientific substantiation of the principles of pharmaceutical correction of polydrug addiction on the basis of forensic pharmacy. Dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Technology of medicines, the organization of pharmaceutical business and forensic pharmacy". Kyiv, 2020. 24 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/1476729.
Malinina N.G. Forensic and pharmaceutical research of the control and permitting system to increase the level of state control over the circulation of precursors in Ukraine. Dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology and organization of pharmaceutical business". Kharkiv, 2010. 24 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0034175.
Petrenko V.O. Organizational and legal research of drug correction of nicotine addiction. Dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology and organization of pharmaceutical business". Kharkiv, 2010. 24 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0036699.
Kuryzheva O.O. Forensic pharmaceutical prevention of addictive addiction and drug crime among minors. Dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology and organization of pharmaceutical business". Kharkiv, 2011. 24 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0048391.
Peresypkin O.V. Forensic and pharmaceutical substantiation of circulation of drugs with psychoactive properties of different nomenclature and legal groups. Dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology, organization of pharmaceutical business and forensic pharmacy". Kharkiv, 2013. 24 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0066533.
Negretsky S.M. Forensic pharmaceutical substantiation of organizational measures to provide drugs for drug addicts addicted to cannabinoids (F12). Dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology, organization of pharmaceutical business and forensic pharmacy". Kyiv, 2016. 24 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0575291.
Shapovalov V.V. Forensic pharmaceutical bases of search of ways of pharmacocorrection of drug patients with deviant behavior within the limits of the state concept of counteraction to drug addiction and drug crime. Dissertation for Doctor of Pharmaceutical Sciences degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology, organization of pharmaceutical business and forensic pharmacy". Kyiv, 2017. 44 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0089067.
Movsisyan A.G. Prevention of addictive dependence on the basis of forensic pharmacy in the formation of a healthy lifestyle among youth. Dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology, organization of pharmaceutical business and forensic pharmacy". Kyiv, 2017. 24 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/0695217.
Shuvera O.V. Forensic pharmaceutical bases of improvement of measures of counteraction at alcohol dependence (F 10.2). Dissertation for PhD in Pharmacy degree. Specialty 15.00.01 "Drug technology, organization of pharmaceutical business and forensic pharmacy". Kyiv, 2017. 24 p. URL: http://irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/ASUA/1256723.
Uzhva L.O. Expediency of criminalizing the offer of undue benefit or bribery. Electronic magazine "Public administration: improvement and development". 2012. No. 9. URL: http://www.dy.nayka.com.ua/?op=1&z=462.
The price of life: how Ukrainian hospitals make money from patients. Volyn news. 28.09.2019. URL: https://www.volynnews.com/news/health/tsina-zhyttia-iak-v-ukrayinskykh-likarniakh-zarobliaiut-na-patsiyentakh/.
Salimova L. Public forum "Let's overcome bribery together!". Prostir.ua. 09.10.2015. URL: https://www.prostir.ua/?news=publichnyj-forum-podolajemo-habarnytstvo-razom.
The doctor "helped" evade military service for bribes. Provincial girl. 17.05.2022. URL: https://provinciyka.rv.ua/22947-lkar-za-habar-dopomagav-uhilitisya-vd-vyskovoyi-sluzhbi.html.
Kogut M. The head doctor of the Zhovkiv district hospital made certificates for evaders. ZAXID.NET. 16.05.2022. URL: https://zaxid.net/golovniy_likar_zhovkivskoyi_rayonnoyi_likarni_robiv_dovidki_dlya_uhilyantiv_n1542850.
Semenyuk A. The director of a hospital in Chernivtsi was arrested for a bribe for transporting a patient. ZAXID.NET, 06.05.2022. URL: https://zaxid.net/direktora_likarni_u_chernivtsyah_zatrimali_na_habari_za_transportuvannya_patsiyenta_n1542
Semenyuk A. The head of the Center for Providing of Administrative Services from Transcarpathia was detained for producing documents for evaders. ZAXID.NET. 14.05.2022. URL: https://zaxid.net/kerivnika_tsnapu_iz_zakarpattya_zatrimali_za_vigotovlennya_dokumentiv_dlya_uhilyantiv_n1542794.
Slobodenyuk O. In Zhytomyr, the SSU detained doctors for bribery who demanded money from a participant of the anti-terrorist operation. Suspilne. 26.05.2022. URL: https://suspilne.media/243541-u-zitomiri-sbu-zatrimali-na-habari-medikiv-aki-vimagali-grosi-vid-ucasnika-ato/.
The doctor of Vynnykivskyi Hospital, who demanded a bribe for disability, was sent under house arrest. Nashi groshi Lviv. 11.06.2021. URL: https://lviv.nashigroshi.org/2021/06/11/likarku-vynnykivskogo-gospitalyu-yaka-vymagala-habar-za-invalidnist-vidpravyly-pid-domashnij-aresht/.
The SSU exposed a doctor who demanded a bribe from the participants of the anti-terroristic operation for registration of disability. SSU. 02.06.2021. URL: https://ssu.gov.ua/novyny/sbu-vykryla-medyka-yakyi-vymahav-khabari-z-uchasnykiv-atooos-za-oformlennia-invalidnosti-video.
Bugaenko T. The Volyn court acquitted the doctor who was arrested for a bribe of UAH5500. ZAXID.NET. 28.04.2022. URL: https://zaxid.net/volinskiy_sud_vipravdav_likarku_yaku_zatrimali_na_habari_55_tis_grn_n1541826.
Tretyakov D.A. Problematic issues of distinguishing between the concepts of "demanding an undue advantage" and "requesting it". Legal bulletin. 2018. Issue 7. Part 2. P. 323-329.
Furdychko was given eight years for receiving a $300,000 bribe. Nashi groshi Lviv 30.07.2021. URL: https://lviv.nashigroshi.org/2021/07/30/furdychku-daly-visim-rokiv-za-otrymannya-300-tys-habara/.
The ex-director of the Institute of Agroecology and Nature Management of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine was sentenced to 8 years in prison. Specialized anti-corruption prosecutor's office. 30.07.2021. URL: https://www.facebook.com/sap.gov.ua/posts/3524706417632516.
Isaev M.V. The Anti-People's Constitutional Court of Ukraine should be immediately dissolved for acquitting and protecting Ukrainian corrupt officials and removing restrictions on the exorbitant salaries of officials and judges. Electronic petitions. Official online representation of the President of Ukraine. 22.07.2021. URL: https://petition.president.gov.ua/petition/120348.
Ovcharov D. Illegal enrichment: how will the new norm of the Criminal Code work. Mind. 07.11.2019. URL: https://mind.ua/ru/openmind/20204085-nezakonnoe-obogashchenie-kak-budet-rabotat-novaya-norma-ugolovnogo-kodeksa.
Levchenko A.V., Temnik K.V., Onishko I.V. Generalization of the judicial practice of handling cases of administrative corruption offenses and some crimes provided for by Chapter XVII of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. Zakon-Biznes. URL: https://zib.com.ua/ua/print/57263-uzagalnennya_sudovoi_praktiki_rozglyadu_sprav_pro_administra.html.
Hlushko I. What is the threat for violating the anti-corruption legislation? Golaw. 12.01.2022. URL: https://golaw.ua/ru/insights/publication/shho-zagrozhuye-za-porushennya-antikorupczijnogo-zakonodavstva/.
Komarnytska M.O. Separate problematic aspects of the main component of the crime provided for in Article 368 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. Scientific bulletin of the Lviv State University of Internal Affairs. 2017. No. 3 P. 147-157. URL: https://www.lvduvs.edu.ua/documents_pdf/visnyky/nvsy/03_2017/18.pdf.
Criminal Code of Ukraine. Verkovna Rada of Ukraine. URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2341-14/page15#Text.
Shapovalov V.V. (Jr), Zbrozhek S.I., Shapovalova V.O. et al. Organizational and legal regulation procedure for circulation of extemporal medicines based on pharmaceutical law. Annals of Mechnikov Institute. 2017. N.4. P. 33-37. URL: http://www.imiamn.org.ua/journal/4_2017/zmist4_2017.html. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.1133771.
Zbrozhek S.I., Shapovalova V.O., Shapovalov V.V. (Jr.) et al. Processing of the control regime of medicines for pharmacotherapy of chronic pain syndrome in the field of palliative aid. Likars'ka sprava. 2019. N.5-6. P.111-118. DOI: 10.31640/JVD.5-6. 2019 (15). DOI: https://doi.org/10.31640/JVD.5-6.2019(15)
Zbrozhek S. Medical and pharmaceutical legislation: normative and legal regulation of healthcare specialists’ activities in Finland. SSP Modern Pharmacy and Medicine. 2021. Vol.1. N.1. P.1-8. URL: https://doi.org/10.53933/sspmpm.v1i1.5. DOI: https://doi.org/10.53933/sspmpm.v1i1.5
Zbrozhek S. Reform of the healthcare system as a basis for streamlining the organization of circulation and availability of medicines for patients in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. SSP Modern Pharmacy and Medicine. 2021. Vol.1. N.2. P.1-32. URL: https://doi.org/10.53933/sspmpm.v1i2.31. DOI: https://doi.org/10.53933/sspmpm.v1i2.31
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Valentyn Shapovalov, Oleksandr Veits
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
